Using with emacs-jupyter

[5183nischal]

Hi, this looks like a very interesting package and I wonder if its possible to use it together with emacs-jupyter package? I'm interested in particular in the gptel integration.

[ElleNajt]

Thanks!

The gptel integration is mostly language agnostic, I think I should be able to patch it so that most of the functionality works for any src_block.

The main exception to that being the code that detects a python specific traceback string in the results to know that the cell failed, so that emacs can send the cell to gptel automatically. Perhaps there's a less janky and more general way to do that checks for a non-zero error code somewhere... and anyway that would probably work just as well for python-jupyter cells.

(I haven't used emacs-jupyter, honestly perhaps I should, since it seems like it has a few of the features that I've added here and then some. Do you recommend it? Does it handle cells with mixed images and text output well?)

[5183nischal]

I really like emacs-jupyter! I create a venv for each project I work on using uv and a corresponding jupyter kernel and can choose kernel for each org file or source block. It allows inspecting objects which is nice and has basic completions support. I have been usinglazy ruff package for formatting the src blocks. And ocassionaly use it to connect remote jupyter session. I really like it and would like to integrate it with some features of your package!

[ElleNajt]

Nice, that all sounds really good.

And it also seems like it handles complex output from cells well (e.g. html output or mixes of images and text)?

That sounds great -- will try to set it up and test the gptel features for it. Thanks for the suggestion!

[ElleNajt]

Just to follow up -- I've been kind of blocked on setting up emacs-jupyter and zmq-emacs in particular ... I'll keep poking at that when I have time, but just wanted to let you know where I was.

Anyway, I don't strictly speaking need emacs-jupyter to pull out the gptel features, since they're general for org-babel source blocks, so probably that's the right direction for me to go in to be helpful.

[ElleNajt]

I made a language agnostic version of the gpt integrations here: https://github.com/ElleNajt/gpt-babel

I tested with python and bash, but haven't tested with emacs-jupyter since I haven't set that up yet -- but anyway maybe go ahead and give it a try?

[5183nischal]

wow thanks! will try and report!