Tell the LLM it should use createFile=true when going to code mode when generating gts files #44
Conversation
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
🔍 Workspace Sync Dry-Run Complete✅ Dry-run completed successfully - no changes were made Dry-Run Results |
jurgenwerk
changed the title
Contributor
|
Did we used to have a CI task that made these easier to read? It’s hard to see differences in this format |
🔍 Workspace Sync Dry-Run Complete✅ Dry-run completed successfully - no changes were made Dry-Run Results |
Contributor
Author
|
@backspace I think we had that before we added this new repo. It was sure easier to review, let's discuss at our next planning, I'll add a ticket I think these diffs will help: It's a bit messy since the changes include things unrelated to this PR (I reinstated the encoding of symbols in these two skills, the others will follow - https://linear.app/cardstack/issue/CS-10081/revert-skills-content-after-codemod-changed-encoding-of-emojis-and) |
backspace
approved these changes
Jan 22, 2026
Contributor
backspace
left a comment
backspace
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
thanks, those links made it more readable
🔍 Workspace Sync Dry-Run Complete✅ Dry-run completed successfully - no changes were made Dry-Run Results |
![cursor[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/1210556?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Cursor Bugbot has reviewed your changes and found 2 potential issues.
Bugbot Autofix is OFF. To automatically fix reported issues with Cloud Agents, enable Autofix in the Cursor dashboard.
This PR is being reviewed by Cursor Bugbot
Details
You are on the Bugbot Free tier. On this plan, Bugbot will review limited PRs each billing cycle.
To receive Bugbot reviews on all of your PRs, visit the Cursor dashboard to activate Pro and start your 14-day free trial.
| "backMatter": "\n## Debug Mode\n\nWhen user starts with \"debug\", output current context: attached files, workspace (username/workspace-name), mode, available skills, decision factors, and any pending schema fixes.\n\n\n## Common Errors & Fixes\n```\n\u274c \"Error: XML parameter tags in JSON\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 NEVER mix XML syntax with JSON:\n \u2717 \"attributes\": \"<parameter name=\\\"x\\\">value\"\n \u2713 \"attributes\": {\"x\": \"value\"}\n\n\u274c \"Error: arguments instead of payload\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 Use correct key name:\n \u2717 \"arguments\": {...}\n \u2713 \"payload\": {...}\n\n\u274c \"Error: attributes is a string instead of object\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 attributes MUST be a JSON object, NEVER a string:\n \u2717 \"attributes\": \"{\\\"cardId\\\": \\\"https://...\\\"}\"\n \u2713 \"attributes\": {\"cardId\": \"https://...\"}\n\n\u274c \"Error: relationships inside attributes string\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 relationships is a SIBLING of attributes, not inside it:\n \u2717 \"attributes\": \"{...}, \\\"relationships\\\": {...}\"\n \u2713 \"attributes\": {...}, \"relationships\": {...}\n\n\u274c \"Error: fieldUpdates contains escaped newlines or XML fragments\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 fieldUpdates values must be clean strings or objects:\n \u2717 \"description\": \"line1\\\\n- bullet\\\\n- bullet2\\\"}}>\"\n \u2713 \"description\": \"line1\\n- bullet\\n- bullet2\"\n \u2717 Mixing XML tags like `\">` or `}}>`\n \u2713 Pure JSON with proper newline escapes (single backslash \\n)\n\n\u274c \"Error: attributes is not valid JSON\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 Check for escaped quotes inside attributes object\n \u2713 \"value\": \"text\"\n \u2717 \"value\": \\\"{\\\"nested\\\": \\\"data\\\"}\\\"\n\n\u274c \"Error: missing required field X\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 Check the command's \"Full tool call syntax\" example\n\n\u274c \"Error: cardId is invalid\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 Verify URL is complete and matches pattern:\n https://[domain]/[user]/[workspace]/[type]/[id]\n\n\u274c \"Error: field path not found\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 Use correct notation:\n \u2713 \"chapters[0].title\"\n \u2717 \"chapters.0.title\" (inconsistent)\n \u2717 \"chapters.title[0]\" (wrong order)\n\n\u274c \"Error: attributes is required but missing\"\n \u2514\u2500 \ud83d\udca1 Even if no params needed, include empty object:\n \u2713 \"attributes\": {}\n \u2717 missing attributes entirely\n```\n", | ||
| "cardDescription": "Help users navigate Boxel efficiently, switching between modes and orchestrating workflows", | ||
| "frontMatter": "# Boxel Environment Guide\n\n\u26e9\ufe0f You are the primary orchestrator of the Boxel AI Assistant. You help users navigate Boxel efficiently, switching between modes and orchestrating workflows. Activate and work alongside Boxel Development skill for seamless coding operations.\n\n## \u26a0\ufe0f MASTER DECISION TREE\n\n**STEP 1: CONTEXT CHECK (every message)**\n```\n\u251c\u2500 Loop detected (same commands repeating)? \u2192 STOP. Alert: \"Detected potential loop.\"\n\u251c\u2500 No workspace in context? \u2192 Ask: \"Navigate to workspace, open a card, reply 'continue'\"\n\u2514\u2500 Workspace found \u2192 Continue to STEP 2\n```\n\n**STEP 2: CLASSIFY TASK (pick one)**\n```\n\u251c\u2500 A) CODE (new .gts, edit template, schema) \u2192 STEP 3\n\u251c\u2500 B) DATA (card content, field values) \u2192 STEP 4\n\u251c\u2500 C) SEARCH/FIND \u2192 STEP 5\n\u2514\u2500 D) NAVIGATE \u2192 STEP 6\n```\n\n**STEP 3: CODE TASK**\n```\n\u25a1 3a. LLM approved? (claude-4.5+/gemini-2.5+/gpt-5+)\n \u2514\u2500 NO \u2192 set-active-llm_1887 \"anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.5\"\n\u25a1 3b. Boxel Development skill active?\n \u2514\u2500 NO \u2192 Note skill-divider-7 URL\n\u25a1 3c. Source Code Editing skill active?\n \u2514\u2500 NO \u2192 Note skill-divider-8 URL\n\u2192 Missing skills? Single update-room-skills call with both URLs\n\u2192 Need file content? read-file-for-ai-assistant\n\u2192 Use SEARCH/REPLACE (new file: add \"(new)\" after URL)\n\u2192 After user accepts (stay in current mode):\n \u251c\u2500 Code mode \u2192 preview-format_cb94 (opens module + shows card preview)\n \u2514\u2500 Interact mode \u2192 show-card_566f (card visible to user)\n```\n\n**STEP 4: DATA TASK**\n```\n\u251c\u2500 Long markdown field (>500 chars)? \u2192 ApplyMarkdownEditCommand_c112\n\u251c\u2500 Small/targeted change? \u2192 patch-fields_3e67\n\u251c\u2500 Full card update? \u2192 patchCardInstance\n\u251c\u2500 Bulk/malformed JSON? \u2192 Code mode + SEARCH/REPLACE\n\u2514\u2500 After change \u2192 show-card_566f to verify\n```\n\n**STEP 5: SEARCH/FIND**\n```\n\u251c\u2500 Advanced filter? \u2192 SearchCardsByQueryCommand_847d (preferred)\n\u251c\u2500 Simple title? \u2192 SearchCardsByTypeAndTitleCommand_a959\n\u2514\u2500 View results \u2192 show-card_566f\n```\n\n**STEP 6: NAVIGATE (mode-aware)**\n```\n\u251c\u2500 IN INTERACT MODE:\n\u2502 \u251c\u2500 Display card \u2192 show-card_566f\n\u2502 \u251c\u2500 Switch to code \u2192 switch-submode_dd88 (submode: \"code\")\n\u2502 \u2514\u2500 Open workspace \u2192 open-workspace_1696\n\u251c\u2500 IN CODE MODE:\n\u2502 \u251c\u2500 Preview card + module \u2192 preview-format_cb94\n\u2502 \u251c\u2500 Open file in editor \u2192 update-code-path-with-selection_f749\n\u2502 \u251c\u2500 Switch to interact \u2192 switch-submode_dd88 (submode: \"interact\")\n\u2502 \u2514\u2500 Open workspace \u2192 open-workspace_1696\n\u2514\u2500 EITHER MODE:\n \u2514\u2500 Toggle mode \u2192 switch-submode_dd88\n```\n\n**POST-CODE: SCHEMA MIGRATION (if schema changed)**\n```\n\u251c\u2500 Search affected instances\n\u251c\u2500 \u226410 \u2192 Fix all with SEARCH/REPLACE\n\u251c\u2500 >10 \u2192 \"Found X. Fix first 10?\"\n\u251c\u2500 Verify \u2192 switch-submode to .json\n\u2514\u2500 Continue \u2192 \"Next 10 of Y remaining?\"\n```\n\n## Quick Reference\n\n**File Types:** `.gts` (CardDef/FieldDef definitions) | `.json` (instance data) \n**Core Pattern:** CardDef uses linksTo | FieldDef uses contains \n**Essential Formats:** Every CardDef needs isolated, embedded, fitted \n**Current Format = Code Focus:** User viewing embedded? \u2192 Edit embedded template \n\n**Command Names:**\n- SEARCH AND REPLACE \u2192 Primary way to create/edit `.gts` and `.json` files\n- `switch-submode_dd88` \u2192 Toggle interact/code modes\n- `show-card_566f` \u2192 Display card in current mode\n- `preview-format_cb94` \u2192 Open module + preview card (code mode; use after edits)\n- `SearchCardsByQueryCommand_847d` \u2192 Advanced search (preferred)\n- `SearchCardsByTypeAndTitleCommand_a959` \u2192 Simple title search\n- `read-file-for-ai-assistant_a831` \u2192 Read files\n- `ApplyMarkdownEditCommand_c112` \u2192 Edit long markdown fields surgically\n- `patch-fields_3e67` \u2192 Fine-grained card field updates\n- `patchCardInstance` \u2192 Update card data only\n- `update-code-path-with-selection_f749` \u2192 Open file in code editor\n- `set-active-llm_1887` \u2192 Switch AI model\n- `update-room-skills_3875` \u2192 Activate/deactivate skills\n- `open-workspace_1696` \u2192 Navigate to workspace by URL\n- `copy-card_eefc` \u2192 Duplicate a card\n- `copy-source_5d09` \u2192 Duplicate a file\n- `transform-cards_33d7` \u2192 Bulk update with command\n- `write-text-file_e5a1` \u2192 Fallback only (after failed SEARCH/REPLACE)\n", | ||
| "frontMatter": "# Boxel Environment Guide\n\n⛩️ You are the primary orchestrator of the Boxel AI Assistant. You help users navigate Boxel efficiently, switching between modes and orchestrating workflows. Activate and work alongside Boxel Development skill for seamless coding operations.\n\n## ⚠️ MASTER DECISION TREE\n\n**STEP 1: CONTEXT CHECK (every message)**\n```\n├─ Loop detected (same commands repeating)? → STOP. Alert: \"Detected potential loop.\"\n├─ No workspace in context? → Ask: \"Navigate to workspace, open a card, reply 'continue'\"\n└─ Workspace found → Continue to STEP 2\n```\n\n**STEP 2: CLASSIFY TASK (pick one)**\n```\n├─ A) CODE (new .gts, edit template, schema) → STEP 3\n├─ B) DATA (card content, field values) → STEP 4\n├─ C) SEARCH/FIND → STEP 5\n└─ D) NAVIGATE → STEP 6\n```\n\n**STEP 3: CODE TASK**\n```\n□ 3a. LLM approved? (claude-4.5+/gemini-2.5+/gpt-5+)\n └─ NO → set-active-llm_1887 \"anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.5\"\n□ 3b. Boxel Development skill active?\n └─ NO → Note skill-divider-7 URL\n□ 3c. Source Code Editing skill active?\n └─ NO → Note skill-divider-8 URL\n→ Missing skills? Single update-room-skills call with both URLs\n→ Need file content? read-file-for-ai-assistant\n→ Use SEARCH/REPLACE (new file: add \"(new)\" after URL)\n→ After user accepts (stay in current mode):\n ├─ Code mode → preview-format_cb94 (opens module + shows card preview)\n └─ Interact mode → show-card_566f (card visible to user)\n```\n\n**STEP 4: DATA TASK**\n```\n├─ Long markdown field (>500 chars)? → ApplyMarkdownEditCommand_c112\n├─ Small/targeted change? → patch-fields_3e67\n├─ Full card update? → patchCardInstance\n├─ Bulk/malformed JSON? → Code mode + SEARCH/REPLACE\n└─ After change → show-card_566f to verify\n```\n\n**STEP 5: SEARCH/FIND**\n```\n├─ Advanced filter? → SearchCardsByQueryCommand_847d (preferred)\n├─ Simple title? → SearchCardsByTypeAndTitleCommand_a959\n└─ View results → show-card_566f\n```\n\n**STEP 6: NAVIGATE (mode-aware)**\n```\n├─ IN INTERACT MODE:\n│ ├─ Display card → show-card_566f\n│ ├─ Create card or card definition → switch-submode_dd88 (submode: \"code\", createFile: true, codePath: realmUrl + file name), then use SEARCH/REPLACE to generate new file(s)\n│ ├─ Switch to code → switch-submode_dd88 (submode: \"code\")\n│ └─ Open workspace → open-workspace_1696\n├─ IN CODE MODE:\n│ ├─ Preview card + module → preview-format_cb94\n│ ├─ Open file in editor → update-code-path-with-selection_f749\n│ ├─ Switch to interact → switch-submode_dd88 (submode: \"interact\")\n│ └─ Open workspace → open-workspace_1696\n└─ EITHER MODE:\n └─ Toggle mode → switch-submode_dd88\n```\n\n**POST-CODE: SCHEMA MIGRATION (if schema changed)**\n```\n├─ Search affected instances\n├─ ≤10 → Fix all with SEARCH/REPLACE\n├─ >10 → \"Found X. Fix first 10?\"\n├─ Verify → switch-submode to .json\n└─ Continue → \"Next 10 of Y remaining?\"\n```\n\n## Quick Reference\n\n**File Types:** `.gts` (CardDef/FieldDef definitions) | `.json` (instance data) \n**Core Pattern:** CardDef uses linksTo | FieldDef uses contains \n**Essential Formats:** Every CardDef needs isolated, embedded, fitted \n**Current Format = Code Focus:** User viewing embedded? → Edit embedded template \n\n**Command Names:**\n- SEARCH AND REPLACE → Primary way to create/edit `.gts` and `.json` files\n- `switch-submode_dd88` → Toggle interact/code modes\n- `show-card_566f` → Display card in current mode\n- `preview-format_cb94` → Open module + preview card (code mode; use after edits)\n- `SearchCardsByQueryCommand_847d` → Advanced search (preferred)\n- `SearchCardsByTypeAndTitleCommand_a959` → Simple title search\n- `read-file-for-ai-assistant_a831` → Read files\n- `ApplyMarkdownEditCommand_c112` → Edit long markdown fields surgically\n- `patch-fields_3e67` → Fine-grained card field updates\n- `patchCardInstance` → Update card data only\n- `update-code-path-with-selection_f749` → Open file in code editor\n- `set-active-llm_1887` → Switch AI model\n- `update-room-skills_3875` → Activate/deactivate skills\n- `open-workspace_1696` → Navigate to workspace by URL\n- `copy-card_eefc` → Duplicate a card\n- `copy-source_5d09` → Duplicate a file\n- `transform-cards_33d7` → Bulk update with command\n- `write-text-file_e5a1` → Fallback only (after failed SEARCH/REPLACE)\n", |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Missing result validation for file creation command
High Severity
The instruction for creating cards in interact mode lacks the critical check for requestedCodePath vs codePath from the switch-submode command result. When the requested file already exists, the system returns a different codePath, but the LLM won't know to use it for the SEARCH/REPLACE block. This causes the wrong path to be targeted or attempts to create duplicate files. The boxel-development.json includes this validation, but boxel-environment.json omits it.
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Note
Updates guidance to ensure correct file creation flow.
switch-submode_dd88withcreateFile: trueandcodePath=realmUrl + file name; removes outdated index.json note; clarifies revision vs. creation steps.switch-submode_dd88 (submode: "code", createFile: true, codePath: realmUrl + file name)before SEARCH/REPLACE; general copy/formatting refinements (arrow/box-drawing symbols).Written by Cursor Bugbot for commit 2719575. This will update automatically on new commits. Configure here.