Skip to content

Conversation

@el-feo
Copy link
Owner

@el-feo el-feo commented Nov 16, 2025

Summary

This PR implements zip-based image delivery for PDF conversions and includes significant code quality improvements across the codebase.

🎯 Key Changes

Zip-Based Delivery

  • All converted PDF images are now packaged into a single zip file
  • Zip file is uploaded to the destination S3 URL instead of individual images
  • API response images field now returns a single zip URL instead of an array
  • Simplifies client integration: single download vs. managing multiple image URLs

Code Quality Improvements

  • Extracted duplicate method calls across 6 modules (AwsConfig, RequestValidator, JwtAuthenticator, PdfConverter, ImageUploader, RetryHandler)
  • Created dedicated ZipBuilder class with A rating and 0 code smells
  • Upgraded PdfConverter from C to B rating in RubyCritic
  • Improved overall RubyCritic score from 85.98 to 87.92
  • Eliminated 9 code smells and reduced complexity across multiple modules
  • Added comprehensive documentation to RetryError class

📊 Metrics

Test Coverage:

  • Line Coverage: 99.83% (586/587 lines)
  • Branch Coverage: 92.64% (151/163 branches)
  • All 609 unit tests passing ✅

Code Quality:

  • RubyCritic Score: 87.64 → 87.92 (+0.28)
  • PdfConverter: C → B rating 🎉
  • AwsConfig: 16.8 → 15.13 complexity
  • RequestValidator: 41.51 → 36.03 complexity
  • JwtAuthenticator: 73.11 → 71.25 complexity
  • PdfConverter: 102.93 → 98.4 complexity
  • Total smells reduced by 9

🔧 Technical Details

New Dependencies:

  • Added rubyzip gem (~> 2.3) for zip file creation

API Changes:

  • Response images field changed from array to string (single zip URL)
  • Response message updated to "PDF conversion and zip upload completed"
  • Destination URL should now be a pre-signed URL for a .zip file

New Files:

  • pdf_converter/lib/zip_builder.rb - A-rated zip creation utility
  • pdf_converter/spec/lib/zip_builder_spec.rb - Comprehensive test suite

Code Quality Improvements:

  • Extracted ENV['AWS_ENDPOINT_URL'] to variables (3 duplicates → 1)
  • Extracted event['body'] to variable (4 duplicates → 1)
  • Extracted body['webhook'] to variable (2 duplicates → 1)
  • Extracted validation_result[:error] to variable (2 duplicates → 1)
  • Extracted temp_pdf.path to variable (2 duplicates → 1)
  • Extracted page_index + 1 to page_number variable (multiple duplicates → reused)

📚 Documentation Updates

  • Updated CLAUDE.md API specification with zip file examples
  • Updated README.md with zip-based usage instructions
  • Added note about destination URLs being for .zip files
  • Added comprehensive comments to RetryError class

✅ Benefits

  1. Simpler Client Integration: Single zip file download instead of managing multiple image URLs
  2. Improved Code Quality: Higher RubyCritic score, less technical debt
  3. Better Maintainability: Reduced code duplication and complexity
  4. Bandwidth Optimization: Zip compression reduces transfer size
  5. Cleaner Architecture: Separation of concerns with dedicated ZipBuilder class

🧪 Test Plan

  • All unit tests passing (609/609)
  • Test coverage maintained at 99.83%
  • RubyCritic analysis shows improvements
  • ZipBuilder has comprehensive test coverage
  • Integration tests updated for new response format
  • Documentation updated and verified

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

This change consolidates PDF conversion output into a single zip file,
simplifying client integration and reducing API response complexity.
Additionally, code quality improvements reduce technical debt and
improve maintainability.

Key Changes:
- Implement zip-based delivery: All converted images are packaged into
  a single zip file and uploaded to the destination URL
- Extract ZipBuilder class: Separate zip creation logic for better
  code organization (A-rated with 0 smells)
- Improve code quality: Extract duplicate method calls across 6 modules,
  reducing complexity and eliminating 9 code smells
- Upgrade PdfConverter: Improved from C to B rating in RubyCritic
- Add documentation: Comprehensive comments for RetryError class

Benefits:
- Simpler client integration: Single zip download vs. multiple images
- Improved code quality: RubyCritic score improved from 85.98 to 87.92
- Better maintainability: Reduced code duplication and complexity
- Excellent test coverage: 99.83% line coverage, all 609 unit tests passing

Technical Details:
- Added rubyzip gem for zip file creation
- Updated API response: 'images' field now returns single zip URL
- Updated documentation: CLAUDE.md and README.md reflect new behavior
- Extracted duplicate method calls in AwsConfig, RequestValidator,
  JwtAuthenticator, PdfConverter, and ImageUploader

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
Copy link

Copilot AI left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Pull Request Overview

This PR successfully implements zip-based image delivery for the PDF conversion service, replacing the previous approach of uploading individual images with a single zip file upload. The changes include significant code quality improvements through extraction of duplicate code and creation of a dedicated ZipBuilder utility class.

Key Changes:

  • Implemented zip file creation and upload workflow using the rubyzip gem
  • Refactored duplicate variable references across multiple modules (AwsConfig, RequestValidator, JwtAuthenticator, PdfConverter, ImageUploader)
  • Created new ZipBuilder class for zip file generation with comprehensive test coverage
  • Updated API response format from array of image URLs to single zip URL
  • Enhanced documentation across README.md and CLAUDE.md with zip file usage instructions

Reviewed Changes

Copilot reviewed 20 out of 21 changed files in this pull request and generated 2 comments.

Show a summary per file
File Description
prompts/completed/001-zip-images-stream-to-s3.md Documents the implementation requirements and approach for the zip-based delivery feature
pdf_converter/lib/zip_builder.rb New utility class for creating zip files in memory from image files with clean API
pdf_converter/spec/lib/zip_builder_spec.rb Comprehensive test suite for ZipBuilder with 100% coverage of zip creation scenarios
pdf_converter/app/image_uploader.rb Refactored to use ZipBuilder and upload single zip file instead of individual images
pdf_converter/spec/app/image_uploader_spec.rb Updated tests to verify zip upload behavior instead of batch image uploads
pdf_converter/app.rb Modified to handle zip URL instead of uploaded URLs array in response
pdf_converter/spec/app_spec.rb Updated tests to expect zip_url instead of uploaded_urls in responses
pdf_converter/app/response_builder.rb Changed success_response to accept zip_url parameter instead of uploaded_urls array
pdf_converter/spec/app/response_builder_spec.rb Updated response builder tests for new zip-based response format
pdf_converter/spec/integration/localstack_integration_spec.rb Updated integration tests to verify zip file upload to S3
pdf_converter/lib/retry_handler.rb Added documentation comments to RetryError class
pdf_converter/lib/aws_config.rb Extracted ENV['AWS_ENDPOINT_URL'] to local variable to reduce duplication
pdf_converter/app/request_validator.rb Extracted event['body'] and body['webhook'] to variables
pdf_converter/app/jwt_authenticator.rb Extracted validation_result[:error] and ENV['AWS_ENDPOINT_URL'] to variables
pdf_converter/app/pdf_converter.rb Extracted temp_pdf.path and page_index + 1 to variables for reuse
pdf_converter/Gemfile Added rubyzip (~> 2.3) dependency
pdf_converter/Gemfile.lock Locked rubyzip at version 2.4.1
README.md Updated with zip file delivery examples and destination URL guidance
CLAUDE.md Updated API specification to reflect zip-based response format
.claude/settings.local.json Added SlashCommand permission for running prompts
pdf_converter/spec/.rspec_status Updated test execution results showing all 609 tests passing

💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.

@el-feo el-feo merged commit 0a4f9ba into main Nov 18, 2025
7 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants